MSCEWI1015

Pivot/Unpivot multiple function not supported.

This is a deprecated version of the SnowConvert documentation, please visit the official site HERE.

Severity

Medium

Description

This section describes the different issues that could be triggered by PIVOT and UNPIVOT clauses. The not supported scenarios are presented in the following table.

	PIVOT	UNPIVOT	ORACLE	TERADATA
MULTIPLE COLUMN	X	X	X	X
RENAME COLUMN	X	X	X	X
MULTIPLE FUNCTION	X		X	X
WITH CLAUSE	X			X
XML OUTPUT FORMAT	X		X
IN CLAUSE SUBQUERY	X		X	X
IN CLAUSE ANY SEQUENCE	X		X
INCLUDE/EXCLUDE NULLS		X	X	X

MULTIPLE COLUMN

Multiple column is not supported by PIVOT and UNPIVOT clauses.

Example Code

Input Code:

SELECT * FROM star1p UNPIVOT ((sales,cogs)  FOR  yr_qtr
    IN ((Q101Sales, Q101Cogs) AS 'Q101A',
        (Q201Sales, Q201Cogs) AS 'Q201A', 
        (Q301Sales, Q301Cogs) AS 'Q301A')) AS Tmp;

Output Code:

SELECT
*
FROM
-- ** MSC-ERROR - MSCEWI1015 - PIVOT/UNPIVOT MULTIPLE COLUMN NOT SUPPORTED **
--     PUBLIC.star1p UNPIVOT ((sales,cogs)  FOR  yr_qtr
--IN ((Q101Sales, Q101Cogs) AS 'Q101A', (Q201Sales, Q201Cogs) AS 'Q201A', (Q301Sales, Q301Cogs) AS 'Q301A')) AS Tmp
                                                                                                                 ;

RENAME COLUMN

Renaming columns with aliases is not supported in snowflake UNPIVOT clauses, Snow Convert is going to remove aliases for functions or columns in order to create a valid query, check that this change does not affect the original functionality.

For PIVOT, the use of column aliases is only supported in SnowConvert for Teradata if the following two conditions are true: all expressions inside the IN clause have an alias associated and Snowconvert has information about the columns that will be generated as result, either by providing the table definition or using a subquery with an explicit column list as input to the clause.

Example Code

Input Code:

CREATE TABLE star1(
	country VARCHAR(20),
	state VARCHAR(10), 
	yr INTEGER,
	qtr VARCHAR(3),
	sales INTEGER,
	cogs INTEGER
);

--SAMPLE 1
SELECT * FROM db1.star1p UNPIVOT (column1  FOR  for_column 
    IN (col1 AS 'as_col1', col2 AS 'as_col2')) Tmp;

--SAMPLE 2
SELECT *
FROM star1 PIVOT (
	SUM(sales) as ss1 FOR qtr                                                                                               
    IN ('Q1' AS Quarter1,                                                                                                     
    	'Q2' AS Quarter2, 
        'Q3' AS Quarter3)
)Tmp;

--SAMPLE 3
SELECT 
	* 
FROM (
	SELECT 
		country,
		state, 
		yr,
		qtr,
		sales,
		cogs
	FROM star1 ) A
PIVOT (
	SUM(sales) as ss1 FOR qtr                                                                                               
    IN ('Q1' AS Quarter1,                                                                                                     
    	'Q2' AS Quarter2, 
        'Q3' AS Quarter3)
)Tmp;

Output Code:

CREATE TABLE star1 (
	country VARCHAR(20),
	state VARCHAR(10),
	yr INTEGER,
	qtr VARCHAR(3),
	sales INTEGER,
	cogs INTEGER
);

--SAMPLE 1
SELECT
*
FROM db1.PUBLIC.star1p UNPIVOT(column1 FOR  for_column IN (col1, col2) /*** MSC-ERROR - MSCEWI1015 - PIVOT/UNPIVOT RENAME COLUMN NOT SUPPORTED ***/) Tmp;

--SAMPLE 2
SELECT
	*
	FROM
	star1 PIVOT(
	SUM(sales) FOR qtr IN ('Q1',
	   	'Q2',
	       'Q3'))Tmp (
			country,
			state,
			yr,
			cogs,
			Quarter1_ss1,
			Quarter2_ss1,
			Quarter3_ss1
	);

--SAMPLE 3
	SELECT
		*
	FROM (
			SELECT
				country,
				state,
				yr,
				qtr,
				sales,
				cogs
			FROM
				star1
	) A PIVOT(
		SUM(sales) FOR qtr IN ('Q1',
	    'Q2',
	        'Q3'))Tmp (
			country,
			state,
			yr,
			cogs,
			Quarter1_ss1,
			Quarter2_ss1,
			Quarter3_ss1
	);

MULTIPLE FUNCTION

Multiple function is not supported for PIVOT clauses, sometimes multiple function queries could be re-written using case statements, see the following Teradata sample for more information https://docs.teradata.com/r/756LNiPSFdY~4JcCCcR5Cw/L0kKSOrOeu_68mcW3o8ilw

Example Code

Input Code:

SELECT *
FROM STAR1 PIVOT(SUM(COL1), SUM(COL2) FOR YR IN ('Y1', 'Y2', 'Y3'))TMP;

Output Code:

SELECT
*
FROM
-- ** MSC-ERROR - MSCEWI1015 - PIVOT/UNPIVOT MULTIPLE FUNCTION NOT SUPPORTED **
--     PUBLIC.STAR1 PIVOT(SUM(COL1), SUM(COL2) FOR YR IN ('Y1', 'Y2', 'Y3'))TMP
                                                                             ;

WITH CLAUSE

Teradata PIVOT has an optional WITH clause, this is not allowed in snowflake's PIVOT.

Example Code

Input Code:

SELECT *
FROM STAR1 PIVOT(SUM(COL1) FOR YR IN ('Y1', 'Y2', 'Y3') WITH SUM(*) AS withalias)TMP;

Output Code:

SELECT
*
FROM PUBLIC.STAR1 PIVOT(SUM(COL1) FOR YR IN ('Y1', 'Y2', 'Y3')
-- ** MSC-ERROR - MSCEWI1015 - PIVOT/UNPIVOT WITH CLAUSE NOT SUPPORTED **
--                                                               WITH SUM(*) AS withalias                                                                                    )TMP;

XML OUTPUT FORMAT

XML output for PIVOT clause is not supported by snowflake.

Example Code

Input Code:

SELECT * FROM   (SELECT product_code, quantity FROM pivot_test)
PIVOT XML (SUM(quantity) 
FOR (product_code) IN ('A','B','C'));

Output Code:

SELECT * FROM (SELECT product_code, quantity FROM MYDB.PUBLIC.pivot_test)
/*** MSC-ERROR - MSCEWI1015 - PIVOT/UNPIVOT XML OUTPUT FORMAT NOT SUPPORTED ***/
PIVOT (SUM(quantity) FOR product_code IN ( 'A', 'B', 'C'));

IN CLAUSE SUBQUERY

Subqueries for IN clause are not supported.

Example Code

Input Code:

SELECT * FROM s1 PIVOT(SUM(COL1) FOR FORCOL IN (SELECT SELCOL FROM S2))DT;

Output Code:

SELECT
*
FROM
-- ** MSC-ERROR - MSCEWI1015 - PIVOT/UNPIVOT IN CLAUSE SUBQUERY NOT SUPPORTED **
--     PUBLIC.s1 PIVOT(SUM(COL1) FOR FORCOL IN (SELECT
--SELCOL
--FROM PUBLIC.S2))DT
                  ;

IN CLAUSE ANY SEQUENCE

This error is triggered when ANY keyword is used in IN clause. This is currently not supported.

Example Code

Input Code:

SELECT * FROM (SELECT product_code, quantity FROM pivot_test)
PIVOT (SUM(quantity)
FOR product_code IN (ANY, ANY, ANY));

Output Code:

SELECT * FROM (SELECT product_code, quantity FROM MYDB.PUBLIC.pivot_test)
-- ** MSC-ERROR - MSCEWI1015 - PIVOT/UNPIVOT IN CLAUSE ANY SEQUENCE NOT SUPPORTED **
--PIVOT (SUM(quantity) FOR product_code IN (ANY, ANY, ANY))
                                                         ;

INCLUDE/EXCLUDE NULLS

INCLUDE NULLS or EXCLUDE NULLS are not valid options for UNPIVOT clauses in snowflake.

Example Code

Input Code:

SELECT * FROM db1.star1p UNPIVOT INCLUDE NULLS (column1  FOR  for_column IN (col1, col2)) Tmp;

Output Code:

SELECT
*
FROM /*** MSC-ERROR - MSCEWI1015 - PIVOT/UNPIVOT INCLUDE/EXCLUDE NULLS NOT SUPPORTED ***/
 db1.PUBLIC.star1p UNPIVOT(column1 FOR  for_column IN (col1, col2)) Tmp;

Recommendations

• Re-write the query if possible, otherwise, no additional user actions are required.

• If you need more support, you can email us at [email protected]